Leonard Fein Took Us Beyond False Dichotomies

Categories: Letters From Leadership, Letters From Leadership

Who Says You Can’t Love Israel and Criticize Its Policies?

“There are two kinds of Jews in the world.

“There is the kind of Jew who detests war and violence, who believes that fighting is not ‘the Jewish way,’ who willingly accepts that Jews have their own and higher standards of behavior. And not just that we have them, but that those standards are our lifeblood, are what we are about.

“And there is the kind of Jew who thinks we have been passive long enough, who is convinced that it is time for us to strike back at our enemies, to reject once and for all the role of victim, who willingly accepts that Jews cannot afford to depend on favors, that we must be tough and strong.

“And the trouble is, most of us are both kinds of Jew.”

The passage above, from Leonard Fein’s “Days of Awe,” appeared in the September 1982 issue of Moment, written after most of the fighting in the (First) Lebanon War had subsided. It is testimony to Leibel’s wisdom, and to his moral prescience. And more important, it reflects his insightful — and inspiring — rejection of forced dualism: the premise that one must choose, as above, between Jewish assertiveness and Jewish compassion, or — his constant theme — between tribalism and universalism. He melded dispassionate academic rigor and engaged social action.

Leibel’s life, thought and action did not so much shatter these and other divisions, or even bridge them; rather, he fused them. It is not merely that the terms “secular” and “religious” apply equally well to Leibel’s ultimate beliefs; rather, both are necessary descriptors for the Jew who is fiercely religiously secular, one who professes not quite to believe in the God, the Jew about whom Leibel wrote almost obsessively and the Jew whom we suspect was Leibel himself.

Leibel was the life-long Jewish social justice activist who (in 2013) could write with conviction, “Social Justice Does Not Need God.” At the same time, of the 1,570 (!) of Leibel’s writings in the “Leonard Fein Collection” in the Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ NYU Wagner, 424 contain references to the God in Whom social justice activists need not believe. Leibel, known for his bons mots, often remarked, “All of Jewish theology may be summed up in the following: ‘If there is one, there’s only one.’”

But nowhere was Leibel’s rejection of false dualism as courageous, influential and important as in his absolute identification of his pro-Israel Zionism, with his incessant and trenchant criticism of the policies of the Israeli government and polity. Let us not forget that this Hebrew- (and Yiddish-) speaking son of the Habonim movement first visited Israel in his teen years and returned innumerable times. Parts of his extended family live in Israel (including an individual high up in Israel’s security establishment), as does his best friend, whose friendship extends back to 1951.

At the same time, this Lover of Zion, this secular activist Jew who (in the words of the Psalmist) never forgot Jerusalem and always “set Jerusalem above [his] highest joy,” wrote voluminously in order to bring tikun (repair) to what he saw as the Israeli government’s politically counter-productive and morally misguided policies. Of those 1,570 items in our archive, 1,170 in some way concern Israel. And for a flavor of his thinking, ponder the titles of some of his most recent contributions (most of which appeared in the Forward): Which Side Has No One To Talk To? The Israeli Rejection of a Two State Solution; Israel Continues To Erase the Green Line; Israel’s Heartbreaking Policy to African Asylum-Seekers (all within the last 12 months — and there’s more!).

These critical views of Israeli policy are the core expression of Leibel’s love of Israel. They are a version not of “Israel, but,” but of “Israel, because.”

The key to Leibel’s thinking here, and so much elsewhere, emerges in Chapter 9 of his 1988 book “Where Are We? The Inner Life of America’s Jews.” Titled “Particularism and Universalism: The Synthesis,” Leibel’s magnificent (and under-noted) chapter contains the following enduringly instructive lines:

“The tension between particularism and universalism is hardly unique to the Jews.… Traditional societies are characterized by high levels of particularism, while the process of modernization induces a growing universalism. Which side are you on? Forced to choose, most of us would surely prefer the modern society to the traditional.… But the key words in the preceding… are, ‘Forced to Choose.’ Who forces?… With respect to the ‘choice’ between particularism and universalism, we must speak, then, of a ‘both-and’ understanding.… We can be both universalistic and particularistic, both rational and traditional, both sentimental and utilitarian.”

On a very personal note, if I may be allowed: Leibel was the last surviving mentor in my life, one who has instructed and befriended me since he asked me to work for and with him in the summer of 1969. And my personal loss is shared by innumerable other mentees, generations of thinkers, activists and others who learned from him and were touched by him.

Our appreciation for his vast contribution only magnifies our sense of loss. May his memory be for a blessing, as it surely will.

Steven M. Cohen is a research professor at Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion and director of the Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ NYU Wagner, home of ”The Leibel Fein Collection.”

Reprinted with permission of the author.

About Steven Cohen, Board Member

Steven M. Cohen is a Research Professor of Jewish Social Policy at HUC-JIR, and Director of the Berman Jewish Policy Archive at Stanford University (www.BJPA.org ). In 1992 he made aliyah, and taught for 14 years at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem. With Arnold Eisen, he wrote, The Jew Within, and with Charles Liebman he wrote, Two Worlds of Judaism: The Israeli and American Experiences. His earlier books include American Modernity & Jewish Identity, and American Assimilation or Jewish Revival? In 2011, he received an honorary doctorate from the Spertus Institute of Jewish Studies. In 2010, he received the Marshall Sklare Award of the Association for the Social Scientific Study of Jewry. The book, Sacred Strategies, of which he is a co-author, won a National Jewish Book Award in 2010. He is married to Rabbi Marion Lev-Cohen, and they live in Tel Aviv and New York. His daughter, Edeet, mother of one, works at the Israel State Prosecutor’s office, and his son Adam lives in New Jersey with his wife and two children.
This entry was posted in Letters From Leadership, Letters From Leadership. Bookmark the permalink.

93 Responses to Leonard Fein Took Us Beyond False Dichotomies

  1. afldudj says:

    10umUf ihdauunateor, [url=http://twrlxwmiteug.com/]twrlxwmiteug[/url], [link=http://vpntlvieigyf.com/]vpntlvieigyf[/link], http://amnvjygabpqg.com/

  2. Way cool, some valid points! I appreciate you making this article available, the rest of the site is also high quality. Have a fun.

  3. An impressive share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was doing a bit of evaluation on this. And he the truth is purchased me breakfast as a result of I discovered it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love reading extra on this topic. If attainable, as you change into expertise, would you thoughts updating your weblog with more details? It’s highly useful for me. Big thumb up for this weblog put up!

  4. Can I simply say what a reduction to find someone who really is aware of what theyre speaking about on the internet. You positively know how one can convey a difficulty to mild and make it important. Extra individuals must learn this and perceive this aspect of the story. I cant believe youre not more standard since you definitely have the gift.

  5. Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So good to search out anyone with some authentic thoughts on this subject. realy thanks for starting this up. this website is one thing that is wanted on the internet, somebody with a bit of originality. useful job for bringing one thing new to the internet!

  6. I will immediately snatch your rss as I can not in finding your e-mail subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Kindly allow me realize in order that I may just subscribe. Thanks.

  7. Really Appreciate this post, can I set it up so I get an email sent to me when there is a new update?

  8. I see something truly special in this web site.

  9. I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post…

  10. visit here says:

    Hello.This article was extremely fascinating, particularly because I was browsing for thoughts on this matter last Sunday.

  11. Jerilyn says:

    Hey there! Quick question that’s completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My weblog looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to fix this issue. If you have any recommendations, please share. With thanks!