Journey to Gush Katif

Categories: Israel
By Judith Gelman

Little suggests that only weeks remain for Ganei Tal, a religious moshav in southern Gaza. The lawns are watered and fresh flowers fill the gardens. The major clue that change is coming is the stream of Orthodox tourists making pilgrimages of support. Tourists never visited Ganei Tal before talk of disengagement?even now, visits by secular, pro-disengagement groups are so rare that FOXNews and Ha?aretz accompanied the tour I joined in late June.

Continuing life in Ganei Tal as if nothing is happening is a purposeful strategy. ?The army will find us going about our everyday life–we will not prepare in anyway? is how our host, Michael, described it. No one in Ganei Tal plans to raise a hand against a soldier; men and women here serve in the army and their lives in Gaza have only been possible with IDF protection. Resistance means making no plans for life after disengagement and waiting for soldiers to carry them away. According to Michael, no one has filled out compensation forms, chosen a new home, or registered children in new schools. He says he will not pack as much as a toothbrush.

We met Michael in his hothouses. His workers dug up, trimmed and packed his amaryllis bulbs as he spoke. This frenzied activity is excusable because this is his regular harvest season. Still, time is of the essence?in six short weeks, the IDF will start removing settlers and then packing their household goods; they will not harvest crops.

We began our encounter warily, but committed to listen politely. Expecting a hostile response, Michael seemed nervous as he recited the arguments against disengagement?Gaza appears in the Torah and so it is part of the Jewish homeland. Palestinians never inhabited these previously barren sand dunes. The settlers? hard work created productive communities. The workers want their employers to stay. Disengagement rewards terror. Abandoning Gaza is the first step to losing Tel Aviv, Haifa and Jerusalem.

When we did not challenge his arguments, our host grew more comfortable and told us his own story. Originally from South Africa, he settled in Ganei Tal 23 years ago. Using his engineering degree, he created a high tech farm–hot water pipes buried in the sand warm his bulbs in the winter; drip lines water them; an aerial system sprays nutrients. He can replicate his greenhouse inside Israel?s 1967 borders, but without the subsidies he received in Gaza, the capital cost may be prohibitive. The operating costs will be higher too?his Palestinian workers earn just a third of Israel?s minimum wage. Growing amaryllis bulbs has been quite profitable for Michael in Gaza, but it could be a losing proposition inside the green line.

For a second time in his life this 56 year-old man faces the prospects of starting life over again, but this time with a less profitable business, in a new community, and in a smaller house. This time he will not be an idealistic pioneer raising his young family. Instead, he is disillusioned middle-aged man who feels betrayed by his government. But the government did not betray him?before he moved to Gaza, Michael, like all settlers, signed a statement acknowledging the government?s right to remove him in the future. Now, the government is calling the option; his family?s heavily subsidized lifestyle must end so Israeli troops can leave Gaza.

Governments around the world uproot their citizens for more mundane reasons than security. The US Supreme Court recently affirmed New London, Connecticut?s right to evict homeowners to make way for a shopping mall. In China, one million people must move to make way for the Three Gorges Dam hydroelectric project. However, in China and Connecticut, no one argued that God gave them the right to stay.

In Gaza, anti-disengagement advocates wrap their arguments in Torah, even though Gaza?s biblical pedigree is weak. The Torah mentions a kfar darom (Southern Village), Samson destroyed a Philistine temple in Gaza, and Abraham farmed land near Beersheba (25 miles outside of the Gaza Strip). Hardly proof that it is Jewish territory. Still, religious settlers claim Gaza as part of the Jewish people?s God-given territorial inheritance. For them, God trumps the Israeli government in determining the boundaries of the Jewish homeland. This religious rhetoric has real consequences: most secular settlers will be gone before disengagement begins; most religious settlers will stay until the end.

Experts who studied the evacuation of Yamit recommend that communities move intact so that evacuees can adjust to their new lives together. However, communities like Ganei Tal, who refuse to discuss the future, may end up divided. Families in these communities have not found housing or new jobs within Israel proper. Their children are likely to start school late, making the transition more difficult. Even the dead, being evacuated along with the living, cannot be reburied until their community chooses a new location.

At one point, Michael, who refuses all contact with the disengagement planning authority, complained that no one has told him the size of his compensation package. Refusing to cooperate and then blaming the government for the results is illogical, but anxiety about the future is natural among those who have made no plans for the day after. And those who plan for their future, or leave early, are seen as traitors.

Leaders of the settlers? movement, who live in the West Bank, show little interest in helping those who must soon leave their homes adjust. Instead of helping Gaza?s settlers prepare for new lives, these leaders hope to bring tens of thousands of people into Gaza in order make disengagement as difficult as possible. These outsiders are not necessarily committed to the nonviolent approach championed by Michael and may escalate the conflict.

No one really expects to stop disengagement. By massive opposition in Gaza, the leaders hope to preclude future withdrawal from the West Bank. Gaza?s settlers are just pawns in this larger battle. After Gaza is empty and the leadership goes home to the West Bank, their pawns may suffer the results of their lack of preparation for years to come. Sadly, the more psychological scars the evacuees carry after disengagement, the better it will be for the settlers? movement as they fight any future moves to leave the territories.

(Judy Gelman recently traveled to Gush Katif with the New Israel Fund’s International Council, of which she is a member.)                     

About Judith Gelman, Vice President and Chair of the Executive Committee

Judith Gelman is the Chair of Ameinu’s Executive Committee and serves as the Chair of the Fundraising and Membership Committee. She also serves on the Executive Committee of the Habonim Dror Foundation and on the Camp Committee for Habonim Dror Camp Moshava, where her three children represent the fourth generation of her family associated with the camp. Prior to attending Oberlin College and MIT, Judith participated in the Habonim’s 23rd Workshop at Maayan Baruch. In addition to her work with Ameinu and Habonim Dror, Judith sits on the International Council of the New Israel Fund and on the NIF DC Local Council. Judy also serves on the Montgomery County, MD Steering Committee for J Street and on the board of a local private high school. She is a former President of Adat Shalom Reconstructionist Congregation in Bethesda, MD. She has previously worked for the Council of Economic Advisers and the Federal Trade Commission, and is currently employed at Salop Economics in Washington, DC.
This entry was posted in Israel. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Journey to Gush Katif

  1. My spouse and I absolutely love your blog and find almost all of your post’s to be precisely what I’m looking for. Would you offer guest writers to write content for you personally? I wouldn’t mind publishing a post or elaborating on most of the subjects you write in relation to here. Again, awesome website!

  2. I was very pleased to find this web-site.I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

  3. tempat abors says:

    whoah this weblog is magnificent i like reading your articles. Stay up the good work! You realize, a lot of persons are looking around for this information, you could help them greatly.

  4. You are my intake, I own few blogs and infrequently run out from post :). “Yet do I fear thy nature It is too full o’ the milk of human kindness.” by William Shakespeare.

  5. I really like your writing style, wonderful info, regards for posting :D. “In university they don’t tell you that the greater part of the law is learning to tolerate fools.” by Doris Lessing.

  6. Just wanna remark on few general things, The website design is perfect, the written content is rattling great. “The enemy is anybody who’s going to get you killed, no matter which side he’s on.” by Joseph Heller.

  7. I really value your work, Great post.

  8. click here says:

    Enjoyed looking at this, very good stuff, regards. “Shared joys make a friend, not shared sufferings.” by Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche.