The Gatekeepers and the Zionist Dream

Categories: Letters From Leadership
Tags: , , , , , , ,

In a recent interview with the Washington Post, Israeli documentary film director Dror Moreh called Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “the worst enemy of Israel.” While Netanyahu has not lived up to his publicly stated commitment to a two-state solution, according to this film he is not considerably different than his predecessors.

Moreh’s Academy Award nominated film, The Gatekeepers, featuring interviews with six former heads of Israel’s security services, the Shin Bet, calls into question many commonly held beliefs about Israel’s true desire for peace with the Palestinians. What is said in The Gatekeepers is not particularly earth shattering; what is astounding is who is saying it — six men who have spent their lives protecting and defending Israel’s security.

One of the film’s themes is that since the Six Day War, no Israeli Prime Minister, with the exception of Yitzhak Rabin, has had any real strategy about what to do with the West Bank and its Palestinian inhabitants. Everything that’s been done has been purely tactical. In this regard, one former security chief claims, there was no difference between Golda Meir (Labor) and Menachem Begin (Likud). While the notion that Israeli political leaders have lacked strategic vision for nearly 45 years is a daunting one, it’s inaccurate. On the contrary, it is because Zionism’s legitimacy among some religious elements requires a commitment to controlling the Land of Israel in its entirety that Israel has not reached peace with the Palestinians.

The Zionist movement has never been monolithic. Since its inception, there have been different streams that have vied with one another (as well as with other currents in the Jewish world) for prominence. Political vs. cultural Zionism, Socialist Zionism vs. Revisionism and religious vs. secular Zionism – these are just a few of the movements that have been at odds with one another. For most of the 20th century, until the ascension of the Likud to power in 1977, socialist Zionism was the prime mover and shaper of the Zionist project. It established the infrastructure for the state in the making that continued to dominate well after Israel’s independence in 1948.

But the socialist Zionist stream, while politically and culturally dominant, was never able to fully actualize its vision of creating a “new Jew,” freed from the negative influences of the Diaspora. To many, this included an unhealthy attachment to a warped and “ghettoized” version of Judaism. The religious streams, for their part, often regarded Zionism with a range of negativity from suspicion to outright heresy, for daring to do the work of the Messiah in restoring the Jewish people to its land.

In the aftermath of the Holocaust, the Zionist movement positioned Israel as a haven for the remnants of a decimated European Jewry and the cornerstone of Jewish revival. The socialist Zionist parties, led by Israel’s first Prime Minister David Ben Gurion, made crucial concessions to religious parties that guaranteed their participation in successive Israeli governments. This participation granted legitimacy to the government of Israel in the eyes of the religious public and gave tacit blessing to the partitioning of the Land of Israel that the UN had made a prerequisite for the establishment of a state for the Jews.

The relationship between secular and religious remained relatively stable until the Six Day War in 1967. After Israel’s “miraculous” victory over its neighbors, there was a fundamental shift in the relationship between Judaism and Zionism. The military victory was heralded by the religious community in Israel and the Diaspora as the onset of the Messianic era – redemption was at hand. The settlement enterprise, consisting of non-religious elements as well — security hawks and people simply looking for affordable housing — was adopted by religious Zionism and has become the foundation of its Zionist identity.

In the heady aftermath of the war, the Israeli political establishment didn’t discourage this new approach and successive governments, including ones led by the Labor Party, literally paved the way for the establishment of Jewish settlements throughout the “liberated” West Bank and Gaza Strip. To greater and lesser degrees, the various governments paid lip service to the notion of peace, but Israel’s commitment was more to continued settlement building than to a repartition of the Land. When forced to choose between peace and territories, Israel has time and again chosen territories. “Shalom bayit,” peace in the home, was deemed more important than peace with its external enemies. Netanyahu is on record in support of a Palestinian state, but under his rule Israel has continued to build settlements, keeping the religious elements of his coalition satisfied, but rendering a Palestinian state a near impossibility.

Contrary to the premise of The Gatekeepers, it’s not a lack of strategy that has prevented Israel from achieving a modus vivendi with the Palestinians; rather it’s an unstated one, rooted in the uneasy alliance between Zionism and Judaism that prevents the establishment of a Palestinian State. Yitzhak Rabin paid with his life the price of touching this third rail of Israeli politics. It remains to be seen if Netanyahu will force the inevitable question of whether Zionism can maintain its legitimacy in the eyes of religious Jews if it gives up claim to the entire Land of Israel. What is known is that the Prime Minister has not seen the film and has no plans to do so in the near future.

About Brad Rothschild, Chair of the Policy and Advocacy Committee

Brad Rothschild currently serves as Chair of the Policy and Advocacy Committee. Besides Brad's important work for Ameinu, he is a documentary filmmaker. From 1995-97, Brad worked as a speechwriter and Director of Communications at the Permanent Mission of Israel to the United Nations. After graduating from Emory University, Brad lived in Israel for two years. During this period he worked as a research associate at the Israel Democracy Institute, a think tank advocating political and economic reform. Brad is a passionate advocate for Israel and is deeply committed to achieving peace and social justice. He lives in New York City.
This entry was posted in Letters From Leadership and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to The Gatekeepers and the Zionist Dream

  1. Zeev Raphael, Haifa says:

    “… What is said in The Gatekeepers is not particularly earth shattering;
    what is astounding is who is saying it — six men who have spent their lives protecting and defending Israel’s security.”

    That, in my opinion, sums it up perfectly!

  2. Jeffry V. Mallow says:

    Brad, a truly trenchant analysis. If only the viewing public could be informed of it.

  3. You are a very clever person!

  4. Bobbie Mier says:

    This internet site is my aspiration, rattling wonderful design and style and perfect articles.

  5. Hello! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site
    with us so I came to take a look. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my
    followers! Outstanding blog and terrific design.

  6. tempat abors says:

    Very interesting subject , thanks for posting.

  7. Unquestionably imagine that that you said. Your favorite justification appeared to be at the web the simplest thing to remember of. I say to you, I certainly get irked whilst folks think about worries that they just don’t know about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the top as neatly as defined out the entire thing with no need side-effects , other people could take a signal. Will probably be again to get more. Thanks

  8. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  9. I carry on listening to the newscast talk about getting boundless online grant applications so I have been looking around for the best site to get one. Could you tell me please, where could i acquire some?

  10. Hello There. I discovered your blog the usage of msn. That is a very well written article. I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I’ll certainly comeback.

  11. Hi , I do believe this is an excellent blog. I stumbled upon it on Yahoo , i will come back once again. Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and help other people.

  12. I am impressed with this website , very I am a big fan .

  13. Christine says:

    Thanks so much for providing individuals with an extraordinarily breathtaking opportunity to check tips from this website. It can be very superb and jam-packed with a lot of fun for me personally and my office colleagues to search the blog a minimum of 3 times every week to read the latest guidance you will have. And definitely, I’m always astounded with all the fabulous tricks served by you. Certain 2 facts in this post are in truth the most beneficial we have all ever had.